Honest criticism for my free verse poem?

Answer this question

  • Honest criticism for my free verse poem?


Answer #1 | 18/12 2013 22:07
"we originate from star dust", "I'll use the full moon as a buoy", "a stellar realization" This is really good material. "deftly dodging in and out" "and without you by my side" and " it's gravitational surface" are some of your weaker points. do not omit these lines, however, do consider rewording/revising them so that they do not sound as awkward. otherwise this is a wonderful piece of literature, and I envy the skill and creativity it must have taken to compose it.
Positive: 38 %
Answer #2 | 18/12 2013 22:15
consider removing the and from the last line. Other than that, this is a great poem!
Positive: 32 %
Answer #3 | 18/12 2013 22:52
Wow this is such an awesome poem! I love the language, the flow, the whole idea. The only criticism I have is this: "black, still ocean of twinkling stars." As soon as you said the stars are "twinkling" you contradicted yourself, since the "ocean" is no longer "still". Maybe try something like "black, coruscating ocean of twinkling stars" instead. Maybe even change the word "twinkling", because it's a bit overused. And in the last stanza you've suddenly changed from future tense to present, and it would sound better if you kept it all the same. Some other alternates you might want to think about: Instead of, "constellations radiating and illuminating the sky", try "lambent constellations illuminating the sky" because too many adverbs don't work well for poetry, as they're a bit awkward. Instead of, "asteroids deftly dodging in and out of each other", try "asteroids deftly dodging each other" because it doesn't make much sense, and "deftly dodging" creates alliteration which is good for flow. Hope this helps! Though I honestly think this is amazing. Do us all a favour and never ever stop writing. :) EDIT: Oh, and the "it's" in line 18 should be "its".
Positive: 12 %

Possible answer

Robert Burns and an analysis of poems, Is there for Honest ... Listen to a verse. Is there for honest ... A Man's a Man features on my CD of Burns poems
Read more
Positive: 38 %
This editor did not want honest criticism, but free ... Included in this book are ten of Logan’s infamous ‘Verse ... About the Author Rory Waterman was ...
Read more
Positive: 33 %
... “Why don’t poets write in rhyme?”, ... my more fully honest answer to the ... skill set required to write a free verse poem ...
Read more
Positive: 19 %
... Graves as a free ... and Criticism of Robert Graves: ... Graves's love poetry and humorous verse from The Centenary Selected Poems ...
Read more
Positive: 10 %

Show more results

Login to your account
Create new account